Netflix's move to get… Reindeer baby The lawsuit was dismissed on Friday by the judge overseeing the case between Fiona Harvey – the alleged inspiration behind Martha in the hit series – and the streaming service.
In June, Harvey sued Netflix for $50 million, alleging “defamation, intentional infliction of emotional distress, negligence, gross negligence, and violations of Harvey's right of publicity, arising from the brutal lies the defendants told about her in the television series.” Reindeer baby“.
The following month, Netflix filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, with creator Richard Gadd saying the series was “emotionally true,” though not the “true story” we mentioned. Reindeer baby Claimed at the beginning of each episode.
It is among the contradictions between fact and fiction Reindeer babyMartha claims she was arrested and convicted of stalking, while Harvey never faced criminal charges for her alleged stalking of Jade. In a decision issued on Friday, Justice R. Gary Klausner largely dismissed Harvey's suit and chose to dismiss it. Netflix's suggestion to reject, diverse Reports.
“There is a big difference between stalking and a stalking conviction in a court of law,” Klausner wrote. “Similarly, there are significant differences between inappropriate touching and sexual assault, as well as between pushing and gouging out the eyes of others. While the Plaintiff’s alleged actions are reprehensible, the Defendants’ statements are of a worse degree and could produce a different effect in the mind of the viewer.”
However, Harvey wasn't entirely victorious in the judge's ruling: Klausner dismissed Harvey's negligence claims and her request for punitive damages — “Plaintiff misses the point,” Klausner wrote of the punitive damage — but allowed the rest of her lawsuit against Netflix to proceed. He continues.
“It appears that a reasonable viewer could understand that the statements regarding Martha related to the plaintiff,” Klausner continued. “The series states that the plaintiff is a convicted felon who sexually and violently assaulted Gadd. These statements may rise to the level of extreme and disgraceful conduct.”
Reindeer baby She recently received several awards at the Primetime Emmys, including Outstanding Limited Series, as well as Outstanding Lead Actor in a Limited Series and Writing (both for Gadd) and Outstanding Supporting Actress for Jessica Gunning for her portrayal of “Martha.”
